Student’s Corner

Is a plastic Christmas tree more sustainable than a real one?

There are many pros and cons when it comes to deciding how you choose to decorate during the holiday season. Some prefer a fresh tree, while others pick their tree from an isle of a store. The demand for trees is at its all time high with the percentage of people purchasing one increasing every year. Whatever your traditions or preferences may be, here are a few reasons to pick either one:

Pricing:

The national average price of a 7’-8’ fresh tree is $78. The 17% increase in price from 2015-2017 could be explained by buyers’ desires to support local businesses. On the other hand, the average cost of an artificial tree is $104. This does not take into consideration Black Friday specials and other possible sales. 

Life Expectancy:

A fresh tree lasts about four to six weeks while a reusable tree’s is six years. It is also important to consider storage space and if your family likes to have the same tree every year. 

Allergies:

Fresh trees may not be the best option for those who are prone to allergies from sap, pollen, or mold. Alternatively, artificial trees are made from metal and plastic so they tend to be hypoallergenic. 

Recyclability: 

About 93% of real trees are recycled each year with major cities like Los Angeles and New York offering free tree recycling. Fresh trees are biodegradable and renewable. Purchasing a potted tree reduces its environmental impact as it will continue absorbing carbon from the atmosphere. Artificial trees are usually made from plastics and contain flame retardants, making them non recyclable. 

 

Written by Emily Su, Class of 2022. 

Photo Credit: Old World Christmas