Blog 1: Summary of “Empathy, Justice, and the Law” by Hoffman

In the extract, “Empathy, Justice, and the Law” by Martin L. Hoffman, the author address the ongoing discussion of whether or not empathy should give way to reason and logic in justice and the law. Hoffman’s main argument is that empathy should continue to play a role in justice and the law but only under certain conditions. He supports this through a number of ways.

Firstly by clearly defining empathy and the different spheres it can manifest, for instance its “meta- cognitive dimension” (Hoffman 231). This is described in the extract as a feeling or response in someone because of another’s adversity while being conscious of the fact that the adversity is not their own and one can only merely imagine the feelings of the next person, which is the main kind of empathy we see in justice and the law (231).

In clarifying these terms Hoffman is enabled to describe the positive role empathy can play in justice and the law, such as its motivational properties. Hoffman claims that, “empathy arousal leads to observers helping victims” (231). as well as leading to a desire for “fairness, reciprocity, equity”, which is vital for justice. Furthermore, Hoffman touches on scenarios where empathy positively influenced laws in the past as in the case of Harriet Beecher Stow’s book, which ultimately contributed to the abolition of slavery and the role empathy played in the desegregation decision in the U.S. Supreme Court. However, in these cases Hoffman also touches on the drawbacks of empathy in justice, where he conveys that empathy on its own is not enough, where he brings out the bias in empathy as well as its fragility (250).

Therefore Hoffman’s main conclusion can be summarized in the statement, “for empathy to play a constructive role it must be linked to a legal concept”.

Work Cited:
Hoffman, Martin L.”Empathy, Justice and the Law”. Empathy: Philosophical and Psychological Perspectives.Ed. Amy Coplan and Peter Goldie. Oxford, UK: Oxford UP, 2011. 230-54.Print.
(2011). pp 230-254. Print

190 thoughts on “Blog 1: Summary of “Empathy, Justice, and the Law” by Hoffman

  1. Within this blog post, the negative roles of empathy and the positive roles of empathy are both mentioned. However, there’s less detail in describing circumstances when empathy didn’t work out or work out right. At the same time, the blog post states that the main argument is empathy should only be utilized within the legal system to an extent, under the control of concrete logic and reason. I would like to learn more about when would logic and reasons be placed against sympathy. On the other hand, the intro was very clear about what Hoffman described within his extract. I agree that Hoffman values sympathy while he still held concern about scenarios when it overrides above reasons. there are also effective quoting/paraphrasing that all evolves around the intro statement, supporting it. Overall, this is a summary with smooth transitions and would give the readers more insight into Hoffman’s ideas.

  2. Within this blog post, the negative roles of empathy and the positive roles of empathy are both mentioned. However, there’s less detail in describing circumstances when empathy didn’t work out or work out right. At the same time, the blog post states that the main argument is empathy should only be utilized within the legal system to an extent, under the control of concrete logic and reason. I would like

  3. he negative roles of empathy and the positive roles of empathy are both mentioned. However, there’s less detail in describing circumstances when empathy didn’t work

  4. blog post, the negative roles of empathy and the positive roles of empathy are both mentioned. However, there’s less detail in describing circumstances when empathy didn’t work out or work out right. At the same time, the blog post states that the

  5. negative roles of empathy and the positive roles of empathy are both mentioned. However, there’s less detail in describing circumstances when empathy didn’t work out or work out

  6. the negative roles of empathy and the positive roles of empathy are both mentioned. However, there’s less detail in describing circumstances when empathy didn’t work out or work out right. At the same time, the blog post states that the m

  7. Poker88 merupakan situs judi online terbaik 2019 yang memberikan layanan terbaik kepada setiap member dengan proses deposit yang super cepat dan tampilan game yang super keren serta kecepatan game yang stabil.

    Dengan bonus new member yang besar dan menggiurkan serta menarik dan penawaran bonus harian yang membuat anda nyaman, Bonus mingguan yang kami bagikan setiap minggu nya untuk anda member setia kami yang selalu bersama kami.

    Poker88 juga menyediakan berbagai jenis game yang menarik pastinya yang membuat anda ingin selalu bermain bersama kami. Kami menyediakan 8 games dalam 1 id otomatis tidak merepotkan anda dan tidak akan membuat anda bosan.

  8. Layanan Terbaik Agen bola Online OLB365 Indonesia

    Bukan hanya masalah banyak jenis permainan saja yang akan anda temukan didalam agen bola online terbaik ini.
    Sebagai pemain pemula dan calon member didalamnya. Jelas anda masih asing dengan masalah layanan terbaik yang sudah disediakan didalam agen terbaik ini. Tenang saja, masalah layanan terbaik akan bisa langsung anda ketahui dengan jelas di OLB365.

  9. dan data sgp secara lengkap untuk memberikan info kepada para pemain togel singapore. Togel singapore merupakan salah satu pasaran togel yang sangat banyak di minati oleh para pemain togel online di karenakan togel singapore belum pernah membuat kekacauan yang mengancam niat main para pemain togel. Togel singapore belum lengkap jika belum di lengkapi hasil pengeluaran sgp dan data sgp di karenakan para pemain togel singapore pasti mencari hasil pengeluaran sgp di saat jam pengeluaran sgp yang biasanya di undi setiap hari kecuali hari selasa dan jumat dan biasanya di undi pukul 17.40 – 18.00 WIB.

  10. Untuk tahun 2019 ini , Kabar pasaran togel singapore semakin banyak dan semakin di gemari oleh seluruh kalangan dari muda sampai tua sekalipun . Dan di tahun 2019 ini banyak yang mencari hasil pengeluaran data sgp lengkap yang akan di jadikan sebuah prediksi sgp oleh para master togel. Maka dari itu kami sudah menyediakan hasil pengeluaran data sgp dari tahun 2015 – 2019 untuk para pemburu https://natsu-pool.com

  11. Ingin mendapatkan tambahan pendapatan ??? Kunjungi situs resmi kami dan daftarkan diri kalian gratis untuk bisa mendapatkan jutaan rupiah setiap harinya saat telah menjadi anggota member kami tanpa adanya undian.

  12. Indipoker merupakan situs layanan judi online Ceme Online dan Agen Judi Idn Poker 88 play terpercaya dengan Game ceme keliling,domino qiu qiu,bandar qq dan capsa susun.

  13. Prediksi Togel Singapore, Hongkong, Sidney, Macau. Data Togel, Data HK, Data SGP, Data Macau. Live Draw Hongkong, Live Draw HK, Live Draw SGP, Live Draw Togel Hongkong, Pengeluaran Data HK, Pengeluaran Data SGP.

  14. Situs Judi Online Paninqq merupakan situs poker online sekaligus agen judi bandarq online terpercaya di indonesia dengan sistem keamanan sekaligus kenyamanan sehingga data-data yang anda miliki tidak akan bocor. Pelayanan Customer Service dari agen poker ini juga sangat profesional, siap melayani member dengan sabar serta akan membantu anda jika mendapatkan kesulitan pada saat melakukan transaksi atau kesulitan-kesulitan lainnya.

    Link Alternatif : http://www.paninqq.org

  15. TOTOBET adalah situs judi TOGEL ONLINE dan memiliki 3 pasaran besar yang sangat banyak peminat nya di indonesia,yaitu toto sdy,toto sgp,dan toto hk serta masih ada pasaran lain nya yang masih bisa anda mainkan di dalam nya, walaupun tidak terlalu banyak peminat nya seperti pasaran di atas tersebut.

    tidak hanya itu saja TOTOBET juga menyediakan LIVE GAME yang akan menghibur anda dengan berbagaimacam game di dalam nya, tentu nya akan menghibur anda sekaligus sambil menunggu angka keluaran pasaran TOGEL yang anda pasang di masing2 pasaran nya.

    kini TOTOBET sudah menjadi agen yang sangat terpercaya karena telah menjadi kata kunci di peringkat pertama google yang artinya saat ini TOTOBET sudah banyak di kenal oleh masyarakat di indonesia sebagai agen yang bisa di percaya dan aman dari hal-hal yang berbau negatif. http://pakladiesdresses.com/

  16. ikuti peraturan cara betting http://www.dewabet03.com
    sports, multiplayer, slots dan live number untuk membuka pasaran taruhan langsung dari bandar professional sehingga anda dipermudah untuk mendapatkan kemenangan. Dan juga tersedia tutorial cara bermain untuk kalian yang baru mengikuti dunia gambling.

  17. HOT TOGEL Adalah Situs Judi Togel yang menyediakan pasaran Togel Singapore, Togel Hongkong, Togel Sidney, Togel Macau, Dongfang Pools, Dan Xinjiang Pools dengan pelayanan 24 jam online dalam proses pendaftaran, deposit dan withdraw.

  18. Chat and Smack Speak whilst you perform, you may deliver a player on tilt! Note to these who play poker online till four a.m.: Gambling isn’t a business. The obvious location for this to happen is in a deck of playing cards.

  19. Empathy is important because it helps us understand how others are feeling so we can respond appropriately to the situation. It is typically associated with social behaviour and there is lots of research showing that greater empathy leads to more helping behaviour.

  20. Permainan poker pastinya banyak di kalangan remaja hingga dewasa yang sangat menggemari permainan poker, apalagi dalam 1 id game ada banyak permainan kartunya silahkan kunjungi situs kami untuk merasakan kenyamanan dalam bermain.

  21. دانلود آهنگ ترکی استانبولی شاد جدید بیس دار دانلود گلچین معروف ترین آهنگ های شاد ترکی استانبولی جدید بیس دار ۲۰۱۹ برای عروسی و رقص و سیستم های صوتی ماشین با کیفیت بالا از گیتار موزیک.
    https://guitarmusics.com/turkish-songs-bass/

  22. Pingback: keuntungan web site Poker Online IDN supaya kamu amati dan penjudi lakukan - BLH Motor 2017

  23. Pingback: kejayaan website IDN Indonesia agar kita dalami terus sobat lakukan | Hemp-Eaz

  24. Pingback: ganjaran situs Poker Indonesia untuk pemain Pelajari lalu pemain mainkan – rvs

  25. Ingin mendapatkan tambahan penghasilan hingga jutaan rupiah setiap harinya???? Kunjungi website resmi kami sekarang juga dan daftarkan diri kalian pada halaman pendaftaran yang telah disediakan untuk kalian.

  26. Selamat siang admin, Bagi kalian yang hobi membaca berita bola kini,INFO BOLA98 telah menghadirkanya untuk anda semua diudpate setiap harinya, dan mempunyai konten-konten unik agar pembaca tidak merasa bosan terima kasih selamat membaca^_^

    BERITA BOLA DUNIA

  27. I am very interested in this article. Hopefully after reading this, I can inspire others. Don’t forget to visit our website, friend YOWINJOKER Is the best choice for online gambling players throughout Indonesia, especially for Games and live casino 198.54.126.88/

  28. Hello, I’m very glad I found your website, I actually found you by mistake, when I was researching on Askjeeve for something
    Other, Nonetheless I am here now and just want to say praise for this extraordinary post and don’t forget to visit our website YOWINJOKER Is the best choice for online gambling players throughout Indonesia, especially for Games and live casino 198.54.126.88

  29. Pingback: menyadari strategi melakoni Judi Poker Online terus trik daftar Judi Poker Indonesia

  30. Pingback: memahami trik-trik mencoba game Poker Online IDN terus cara daftar permainan IDN Online

  31. Lol bebek boyama sayfaları ile çocuklar güzel karakterleri boyayıp eğlenceli zamanlar geçirebilir. Boyama ile çocukların el becerileri ve görsel zekaları gelişir ve daha ılımlı bir karaktere sahip olurlar. Lol bebek boyamalarla eğlenceli saatler geçirip, güzel bir etkinlik yapabileceksiniz. En popüler lol karakterlerini en güzel şekilde siz boyayın. Boyama sayfalarını farklı kaydedip bilgisayarınıza indirip bir yazıcı yardımıyla çıktı alıp çocukların boyamaları için kullanabilirsiniz.

    https://www.egitimdili.com/lol-bebek-boyama

  32. 2020 yılında polis maaşları polis olmak isteyen adaylar tarafından merak ediliyor. 2020 yılında polis olup Emniyet Genel Müdürlüğü bünyesinde çalışan bir polis memuru ne kadar maaş almaya başlar? İşte bütün merakınızı gidermek amacıyla kamuvakti.com sitesi olarak Ocak 2020 zamlarıyla birlikte polis memurlarının ne kadar maaş aldığını yazdık. Maaşlar çalışma yılına göre ve kıdeme göre değişkenlik gösterebilmektedir. Bütün kıdem ve detayları bu haberimizden öğreneceksiniz.

    https://www.kamuvakti.com/polis-maaslari

  33. You were great and everyone received so much from your experience and knowledge
    Absolutely amazing, thank you for sharing your knowledge with me.

  34. VARİS TEDAVİ
    Varislerin tedavisi yukarıda anlatılan yöntemler ile yapılır. Öncesinde varisli damar ya da damarlar tespit edilir. Varisli damarların görüntülenmesi yapılarak, işlem sadece bu damarlar üzerinden yürütülür. Bütün yöntemler çok kısa seanslar şeklinde uygulanır. Hastaların çoğu, uygulamanın ardından hiçbir şikayet hissetmezler. Çok azında iğne izi oluşabilir ancak bu izler kısa sürede kaybolur.

  35. Hi all, I am Luna. I am pretty new here so please be patient with me.
    I go to a lot of concerts, but my favorite singer is Travis Scott.
    I’m currently studying to be a Merchandise ISC888 manager which is what I’ve always wanted to do.
    I think the one thing

  36. Blog yang sangat bagus dan menarik. Saya mendapat informasi menarik untuk situs kami. Apakah Anda memiliki tips atau untuk calon penulis? Terima kasih atas artikel ini yang sangat membantu. Diberkatilah Anda. Daftar Judi Game Tembak Ikan :
    Yowinjoker

  37. anda bisa mencoba website terbaik dan juga terpercaya dengan berbagai konten dan juga promo yang menarik di website kami , ayo klik http:// jppk.org sekarang agar anda bisa mengakses situs website kami dengan aman.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.